| |
“Network marketing is exploding all around
the world!”
“Fortune 500 companies are going MLM….”
“More millionaires will be made in network marketing
than in any other business….”
“Network marketing is
reaching critical mass!”
“Network marketing is
achieving momentum—now!”
“Network marketing is the
wave of the future—you better get in
today!”
Are you ready for the
“coming MLM boom”? From the sound of all that amazing
enthusiasm, you’d better be, or you’ll be missing out, big-time! Or is all of that just the MLM choir
singing hopefully and hysterically to itself? Just more
of the same old network marketer’s hype and hustle? In
my dozen-plus years as an author and editor in network
marketing, I’ve heard these rallying cries thousands of
times. And I sure would love to believe them—but I
don’t…
…or didn’t, anyway. Until now.
Whenever I want the TRUTH about NETWORK MARKETING (in capital letters), I ask Leonard Clements.
An acclaimed author and industry analyst, Len founded
the highly regarded “watchdog” publication MarketWave. In my opinion (and experience), he is
the most honest and knowledgeable network marketing
industry expert we have. I ask Len because I know he does his homework. He is both advocate and devil’s
advocate; he believes only what he sees in black and
white.
Len had an idea for an exposé that
would tear apart those excited headlines and hysteric
hyperbole—tear ‘em apart with Len’s favorite tool, the
facts. He was on a mission to expose these gross
exaggerations, distortions and fabrications. Why?
Because Len loves this industry and its people, and is
convinced that such lies will destroy us—if lies they
be.
So Len dove in to set the record straight.
You’ll never guess what happened.
He changed his mind: 180 degrees!
Not only did Len establish the proof of
the truth of those “MLM is about to explode!” claims,
his research also dug up more and better reasons than
ever before to show that network marketers are in fact
in for the ride of their lives! Is this like buying gold at $43 an
ounce? Getting in early on those real estate explosions?
Buying dot-com and tech stocks in the early 90s?
Listen to Len—and judge for yourself.
— John Milton Fogg
For the first time in
history there are solid, logical, verifiable, reasons
for you to believe in a forthcoming network marketing
boom. Eight reasons, in fact—any one of which could
result in a significant expansion of network marketing
in the US alone over the next few years. And these eight
factors will soon be coming together to create a
“perfect storm”—the convergence of powerful economic,
demographic and psychological factors all hitting at the
exact same time and place.
Finally, you and I can honestly make
the claim that there really IS a “network marketing
explosion” on the horizon. It absolutely will happen,
and here’s why:
The Eight Reasons
#1: The Economy. What’s bad economic
news to most people is good news to network marketers.
And there’s a lot of “good news” today.
#2: Demographics. Not only is the pool
of eligible prospects increasing at unprecedented
levels, but that segment of society most ready, willing
and able to pursue network marketing is also
exploding.
#3: Wall Street. Securities investors
look for companies and industries that are about to rise
up fast, and they are looking closely at network
marketing right now.
#4: Supply and Demand. The greatest
inhibitor of our industry’s growth the last few years
has been a huge supply-side glut of networking
opportunities. That’s already changed.
#5: New Blood. Our entire industry
is about to go into momentum for the same reason
individual networking companies enter momentum: a
massive influx of folks who’ve never been in network
marketing before.
#6: Positive Media Exposure. If the mainstream
media could only find a way to make money from this
typically non-advertising industry, would they have a
much greater incentive to promote the positive side?
Yes, they would. They’ve found a way.
#7: Federal Regulation.
I know it sounds
scary; it’s not. In fact, more and better laws will be
the #1 legitimizing catalyst to the network marketing
explosion.
Last, and certainly not least:
#8: Current Trends
The current,
positive and powerful growth trends of the network
marketing industry itself.
Interesting? Exciting? You bet!
Let’s look at each of these eight solid
reasons in detail.
1 The Economy
What’s bad economic news to most people is good
news to network marketers. And there’s a lot of “good
news” today.
I’ve always believed that, sure, the
state of the economy exerts some influence on our
business—but not significantly. (I mean, was there ever
an economy where people didn’t want more money and free
time?) When I began to do some digging to support my
contrarian position, I soon learned I was wrong. First
clue: one of the strongest growth phases in network
marketing history occurred from 1990 to ‘92—coinciding
with the last economic recession. And there was so much
more.
Comparing the popularity trends of
network marketing to unemployment rates, on a
semi-decade basis, yields some exciting revelations.
Network marketing was born in the
1930s—perhaps significantly, in the midst of the Great
Depression—but it began in earnest in the 1950s. It was
far more popular in the second half of the 50’s than the
first. Not a single company of consequence launched from
1950 to 1955, yet the following four years saw the birth
of industry giants Shaklee, NeoLife, and Amway. In the
first half of the decade, unemployment averaged four
percent, reaching 2.9 percent in 1953—the second lowest
in US history. In the second half of the decade, it
averaged 5.3 percent, reaching its highest level since
the Great Depression (6.8 percent in 1958).
[Networking Times has an editorial
policy of not using networking company names in our
coverage. We felt that the historical references in
Len’s cover story demanded an exception to this
rule—Ed.]
In the first half of the 60’s all types
of direct sales continued to flourish. Mary Kay
Cosmetics started in 1963; Avon, Fuller Brush and
Tupperware all achieved momentum. The industry continued
to grow from ’65 to ’69, but not nearly at the same
pace. And guess what? The unemployment rate of the first
half-decade was significantly higher than that of the
second, when 2.5 million unemployed people went back to
work.
Network marketing was thriving during
the first half of the 1980’s, as unemployment continued
to rise. In 1982 unemployment was at its highest level
in 40 years (9.7 percent). During the later 80’s, an era
of MLM “slump,” unemployment dropped considerably; by
decade’s end the number of those out of work was barely
half what it was at the decade’s beginning.
| What’s bad economic news
to most people is good news to network marketers.
And there’s a lot of “good news” today. |
The 1990’s saw perhaps the clearest
distinction between halves of any decade. The first half
saw more major company launches and more companies going
into momentum than any other time in history. There was
also more wealth being created through network marketing
from 1990 to 1994 than in any other five-year period.
The second half was not exactly the
best of times for network marketing. If there is such a
thing as an “MLM recession,” we had one from 1996
through 1999. Why? The very high unemployment rate from
1990 to ’94 dropped sharply during the second half of
the decade, hitting a 30-year low at 4.2 percent in
1999.
The only exception to this
half-century-long pattern is the 1970’s, but that was an
exceptional decade for this industry.
Remember the last half of the 60’s?
Industry growth slowed as unemployment dropped to a
post-war low. During the first half of the 70’s, network
marketing started rocking as unemployment rates jumped.
Unfortunately, all that rocking rocked some boats. The
result: more than five times as many MLM-related
lawsuits from 1970 to 1974 than in all of the 50’s and
60’s combined. 1975 saw a federal action that
essentially questioned the legality of network marketing
itself.
Fortunately, one company, Amway, had
the financial ability to defend itself and the entire
multilevel marketing industry. The case lasted until
late 1979, when the court ruled in favor of Amway. As a
result, there was—for the first time ever—a clear
delineation between illegal pyramids and legitimate
network marketing companies. A fairly dark cloud hung
over the industry for the last half of the 70’s, and
there was not much expansion, despite even higher
unemployment rates. The last and arguably greatest network
marketing growth phase began in 1990, the same year the
US went into our last economic recession.
1980 to ’84 were boom years for network
marketing; we experienced recessions in 1980, part of
’81 and most of ’82.
1970 to ’74 were also boom years for
our business; the economy was in recession for almost
all of 1970 and 1974.
The last half of the 50’s and into the
early 60’s were years of great MLM expansion; the
country was in recession from ’57 to ’58 and most of
1960.
Most recessions last 12 to 18 months;
however, the end of a recession doesn’t necessarily mean
the end of a slumping economy or high unemployment.
We’ve had eight recessions in the last 50 years; during
the 12 months immediately following the “end” of each,
unemployment actually rose!
Every severe economic downturn in the
last 50 years has been during or immediately preceding every period of substantial network marketing expansion.
Strong evidence. And we’re only on
Reason Number One! Let’s talk about an even more
powerful justification to believe in a coming network
marketing explosion.
2 Demographics
Not only is the pool of eligible prospects
increasing at unprecedented levels; that segment of
society most ready, willing and able to pursue
networking is also exploding.
There were about 76 million babies born
between 1946 and 1964, at the time accounting for almost
one-third of the entire US population. Since then, it
has been glaringly obvious exactly where this giant
bubble in the population is at any moment in time,
simply by looking at what products are most popular.
When it comes to charting the market
size for what most network marketing companies offer,
we’re not even half-way up the Baby Boom curve yet! The
market for products that will make us look and feel
younger is going to continue to expand most dramatically
over the next five to 10 years, as the Boomers reach
their 50s and 60s.
The Baby Boom is exciting for an
altogether different reason, too. Virtually all network
marketing companies require distributors to be at least
18 years old. Guess what happened about 25 years after
the baby boom? Those 76 million Boomers had about 75
million babies. About 41 million of them will turn 18 over the next seven years. At no other time in
history, other than the original Baby Boom itself, have
this many people been added to the body of eligible
network marketing prospects in this short a period of
time.
Of course, the people eligible to join is not as important as the number who actually
join. The Direct Selling Association (DSA) conducts an
annual survey of salespeople in the industry. (Roughly
two-thirds of “direct sellers” are network marketers.)
According to their figures, there was a net gain of
400,000 direct sellers from 1997 to ’98; a 600,000 net
gain from ’98 to ’99; and a 700,000-distributor gain
from ’99 to 2000. Not only is the number of people
increasing, but the increase is increasing!
Extend current growth for another 10
years and you end up with 4.7 million additional network
marketers. It took network marketing over 50 years to
grow to 7.5 million—and we are conservatively projecting
an additional 4.7 million in just the next 10 years! (By
the way, that also means the average networking
organization will be 37 percent larger!)
According to Gallup Polls, Americans
first decide to invest in a residual income-producing
vehicle, such as stocks, bonds, real estate, or perhaps
in a business venture, at the average age of 42. The
average age when we invest the most into such devices is
47. Graph the number of 42- to 47-year-olds in the US
and you find that starting about 1988, the line begins
to point upward at almost a 45º angle as the Boomers
started turning 42—and that line continues to rise at a
level never before seen in history all the way to the
year 2009.
We are barely past the halfway point of
that dramatic upward curve!
Does this really benefit us as network
marketers? Are 40-somethings more open to network
marketing opportunities?
The average American is 36 years old.
According to a MarketWave survey of over 6000
network marketers from 1990 to 2000, the average network
marketer is 38.6, and that number has consistently risen
over the years. An exceptional number of those over 40
do participate in network marketing, and this segment of
the population which is most ready, willing and able to
invest in a residual income business venture is going to
continue to increase dramatically for another seven
years!
3 Wall Street
Securities investors look for companies and
industries that are about to rise up fast; thousands of
analysts are looking closely at network marketing right
now.
Professional investors are a pretty
savvy group of people. Based on their due diligence,
they eventually invest their funds in companies whose
growth (and profits) they expect to go up. What do they
see when they turn their magnifying glass on network
marketing companies?
There are over 20 publicly traded
network marketing companies, but the bottom third are so
small I’ll focus on the top 12 well-established
companies. If you were to chart their stock price over
the last five years, starting with December 1996, in
almost every case you’d see a line that looks a lot like
the path of an airplane—coming in for a landing.
With few exceptions, network marketing company stock
values flattened at their all-time lows and stayed there
for about two to three years.
Clearly, Wall Street was not impressed
with network marketing’s growth potential during the
last half of the 90’s.
What do they see now?
The benchmark S&P 500 reached its
peak in September of 2000; by mid-December 2001, it was
down by 23 percent. Over the exact same period our index
of the top 12 network marketing companies was up by
7.3 percent! And all of a sudden, in the last 12
months, these network marketing companies are
outperforming the overall stock market by over 30
percent. That level of performance really gets investors’ attention!
4 Supply and Demand
The greatest inhibitor of MLM growth the last few
years has been a huge supply-side glut of networking
opportunities. That’s already changing.
Anyone with even a C in Economics 101
can tell you about “supply and demand”: an industry
booms when demand dramatically increases. Tremendous
increase in supply results in a down-turn. Sure enough,
during the massive proliferation of network marketing
companies in the latter 90’s, we had a deep industry
slump.
Based on a survey of network marketing
company software suppliers, over 4900 network marketing
companies opened from 1994 to 1997; there is anecdotal
evidence to show that there were about 3600 start-ups in
1998 and 1999 alone. Even more troubling, perhaps half
of all MLM start-ups don’t go to the major software
houses, but rather hire in-house programmers—so the
actual number of start-ups could have been double these
figures.
Bottom line: as many as 13,000 network
marketing companies may have launched from 1994 through
1999; there were at least 8000. But we had a net gain of only about 600 companies—from 900 to 1500. (Have
you ever heard the claim that 95 percent of all network
marketing companies fail in their first two years? I
thought that was a scare tactic spread by older
companies, but these surveys say it’s true.)
| Since the beginning of
2000 the number of start-up companies has declined
significantly. This, along with the increasing
number of company mergers and acquisitions, will
only make the industry stronger. |
During this same time period, the
number of network marketers in the US increased from
about 5 million to 7.5 million. The number of
distributors went up about 50 percent—but the number of companies increased by three times that
much! This means that the average networking downline
actually shrunk by 40 percent. No doubt about it: in the
last half of the 90’s, the supply of MLM opportunities
far exceeded demand.
What’s the good news? First, since the
beginning of 2000 the number of start-up companies has
declined significantly. This, along with the increasing
number of company mergers and acquisitions, will only
make the industry stronger. When more and more companies
were entering the market, the available distributor base
was spread thinner and thinner, resulting in smaller
downline organizations, higher attrition, and generally
far fewer success stories. But think about this: if
there were just as many distributors but half as many
companies, the average downline would be twice as big!
I’m not suggesting the number of
companies will contract to half, but any reduction in
supply will certainly help increase demand, which will
then expand the number of those men and women getting
into profit and reaching their income goals. The more
success stories we have, the more motivation and less
resistance we have to building our organizations even
larger—and the cycle continues upward, rather than down
or flat as it has in the past.
5 New Blood
Our entire industry is about to go into momentum
for the same reason individual network marketing
companies enter momentum: a massive influx of folks
who’ve never been in network marketing before.
Almost every network marketing company
today would like to think they are about to “go into
momentum.” Momentum, as it applies to network marketing,
is the stage in a company’s growth cycle where sales
volume begins to increase geometrically and the company
doubles, triples, and perhaps even quadruples in size in
a very short period of time. Most momentum phases last
about six to 24 months.
Much like buying a stock right before
it goes up in price, most networkers want to attach
themselves to a company right before it explodes. Thus,
practically every distributor will try to make a case
that their company is “about to go into momentum.”
How do they know?
They don’t. No one knows exactly when
the momentum phase will kick in, but much like stock
picking, we can look for clues—historical trends and
patterns to help us make better guesses.
An analysis of all the successful major
network marketing companies shows that every momentum
phase in MLM corporate history was facilitated by
massive numbers of people moving into the
opportunity—either as reps or customers—who had never
been involved in network marketing before. Momentum
is never the result of people moving from one company to
another; it is caused only by a massive injection
of new blood.
Where will this new blood come from?
Today in the US, a little over seven million people
participate in network marketing—which means that about
270 million don’t! How are we going to reach those
massive numbers of people we’ve never been able to reach
in the past? The Internet.
| Our entire industry is
about to go into momentum for the same reason
individual network marketing companies enter
momentum: a massive influx of folks who’ve never
been in network marketing before. |
The Internet began to come into its own
around 1996; by 1998 the number of people on the Net had
almost tripled. Today over 60 percent of adults are
online; experts predict that virtually all Americans
will be using the Internet in some capacity by the year
2010.
The network marketing industry cut its
Internet teeth painfully from about 1997 to early 2000.
As with so many other industries, there were a lot of
network marketing dot-com failures. Some were ugly;
legal abuses resulted in several well-publicized
closures.
For the most part, networkers were a
little over-zealous with this amazing new technology, in
a magical-mystical attempt to have it build our networks
for us. The result was big recruiting numbers, but very
little sales volume and overwhelming attrition.
As the smoke clears, what is emerging
is what the responsible, visionary companies knew all
along: the awesome power of the Internet lies not in
having it do all the work for us, but in having it help
us present our products and opportunities faster, less
expensively, and to far, far greater numbers of people.
New people—people who’ve never been
exposed to network marketing before.
6 Positive Media
Exposure
If the mainstream media were to find a way to
make money from this typically non-advertising industry,
would they have a much greater incentive to promote the
positive side? Yes, they would. They’ve found a way.
Radio, television, magazines and
newspapers all exist primarily on advertising dollars.
But network marketing doesn’t advertise in the
mainstream media. (After all, we’re the “word of mouth”
business.) Not only has the media had no financial
incentive to promote network marketing, it actually has
a financial incentive not to.
Now that, too, is changing. The
mainstream media is discovering how to cash in on
network marketing.
The first big step in this direction
was back in 1994, when Success magazine published
a lengthy and extremely positive cover story about our
industry and its people. The people of this
credibility-starved industry sold out the entire run of
that issue; Success broke their all-time
single-issue sales record by almost double! The result
was a lot more positive portrayals of network marketing
companies in future issues. But even this isn’t where
the greatest promise lies in terms of positive media
exposure.
Picture this: instead of paying for an
advertisement, what if a network marketer worked out an
arrangement where he sponsored the publication itself,
got the ad for free and the resulting sales volume and
downline commissions that were generated from the ad
went to the magazine? They could potentially make far
more income from overrides than from ad fees, even long
after the ads stop running. It’s more than just a
win-win scenario—we get the positive press and the media
gets even more money than if they charged us for the
ads. But would it work?
It’s already working. Slowly, quietly,
such a movement is taking place. More than 100 radio
stations in the US are currently attempting such a plan;
some are succeeding admirably. Virtually the entire
network marketing industry is oblivious to the fact that
this is happening, but it’s simply a matter of time
until the media grapevine picks up on this phenomenal
new ad revenue resource.
Let’s not overlook the public image
boost we’re getting from the various athletes,
celebrities, political figures and medical authorities
whom network marketing is attracting like never before.
Not all are paid endorsers. Many have careers based on
their reputation and positive image and they’ve openly
and willingly attached their good names to network
marketing. What’s more, well-respected mainstream
authors and keynote speakers, such as Richard Poe, Paul
Zane Pilzer, Mark Victor Hansen, Brian Tracy and Robert
Kiyosaki, are now extolling the virtues of network
marketing. This kind of powerful, third-party validation
has never happened before. It’s just starting, and it’s
growing fast!
7 Federal Regulation
I know it sounds scary; it’s not. In fact, more
and better laws will be the principal legitimizing
catalyst of the network marketing explosion.
Recall that in the first half of each
decade, network marketing historically outperforms the
second half. That’s been the case for the last 40 years,
and there were more than purely economic reasons for
this. The regulatory climate has also effected the
performance of the industry, the most obvious example
being the famous slew of federal actions back in the
70’s.
Legal attacks by state or federal
authorities on high-profile network marketing companies
do occur from time to time. (Curiously, they seem to
peak in pre-election years—surely just a coincidence.)
Most of those larger companies, by the way, not only
survive the attack but also come to be considered models
of legality whose policies and enforcement systems are
emulated by younger companies.
There have been many instances of true
pyramid schemes being shut down. Typically the action is
described as, “this network marketing company was shut
down because it was an illegal pyramid scheme.” It
drives me nuts when I hear someone say that. It’s like
saying, “This really honest man was exposed as a liar.”
Well, then he wasn’t an honest man, was he? Either
you’re an illegal pyramid scheme, or you’re a network
marketing company. You can’t be both.
I want to make this very clear: Illegal
pyramid schemes often try to disguise themselves
as network marketing companies, because they want to appear legal. Unfortunately, when the press
reports on illegal pyramid schemes, we all suffer guilt
by association, and that does have an effect on our
ability to retain good people and acquire new ones, at
least temporarily.
No one knows exactly when;
it could be next month, it could be next year. It
could be any time in the first half of this
decade. All I know for sure is this: if you get
involved now and stay involved, you will be there
when it happens. |
The good news is that in the last few
years, we’ve seen no significant legal attacks on
network marketing companies, and several closures of
illegal schemes. Not only does this make the industry
stronger due to a smaller, higher quality pool of legal
opportunities, but it also increases our ability to
build businesses because we don’t have the negative
public stigma creating greater resistance toward the
industry and its opportunities. It also demonstrates a
greater ability among regulators to delineate between
pyramids and legitimate network marketing programs. This
is especially encouraging and comforting to those
networkers who’ve built substantial incomes in “high
profile” opportunities, or those who intend to.
Once again, I’ve saved the best news
for last: There is active, professional lobbying going
on right now by the Direct Selling Association
(DSA) and others to enact legislation that will create
federal regulation of network marketing.
Right now, operating a network
marketing company in the United States is something like
trying to do business in 50 different countries. Each
state has its own set of laws pertaining to business
opportunities, some specifically about network or
multilevel marketing, and all have statutes pertaining
to pyramid schemes. For the most part, each state’s
definition of an illegal pyramid is consistent with the
other 49—but the interpretation and application of those
laws has been somewhat haphazard and arbitrary over the
years.
It’s true that there was a significant
legal precedent created by the federal court’s decision
in the Amway case in 1979, but still, enforcement
actions have been inconsistent, not only between state
and federal precedent, but from state to state—sometimes
even from case to case within the same state.
(Many of these cases involve judicial
opinions as to whether a distributor’s personally
consumed products should be recognized as legally
commissionable sales. This is the focus of the federal
legislation currently being proposed; several states,
including Texas and California, have already recognized
such volume as bona fide.)
Not only will unified federal
regulation create a clear, consistent path for all
network marketing companies and state regulators to
follow, but also, much like the federal regulation of
franchising back in the 60’s, it eventually will require
true and full disclosure. If this does come to pass, and
many believe it will, it will absolutely be a good
thing—very good. Not only will it tremendously
strengthen the industry by weeding out the bad apples;
it will also cause the massive turnover rate among
start-up companies to drop to a fraction of the current
level. They won’t start up in the first place—and the
ones that do launch will have to be serious players with
solid backing. More distributors will be involved in
fewer companies, and those businesses will be only the
highest quality opportunities. Federal regulation will
also greatly increase the respect and credibility of our
industry. This will create a tremendous boost to all
established US-based network marketing companies. Some people are apprehensive about the
prospect of federal regulation. They fear regulators may
throw their entrepreneurial baby out with the legal
bath-water. Not a chance. Not only are there over 1500
network marketing companies in this country, employing
tens of thousands of taxpayers and generating billions
in sales and corporate tax revenue, there are also about
five million network marketers who are also registered
voters. Not a huge percentage, perhaps, but as the 2000
Presidential election clearly demonstrated, it’s enough
to make a huge difference in who has the political power
in this country.
I’ve heard the argument made that back
in 1963, Congress came within 11 votes of outlawing
franchising. Not only did they not do so, but the
post-regulatory era of franchising, in fact, created an
industry that now moves over one-third of all the goods
and services in this country! Federal regulation was the
catalyst to the biggest boom in entrepreneurial history.
Not only do I not fear the concept of
federal regulation, I find the vision of this new era of
network marketing to be absolutely
exhilarating!
8 Current Growth Trends
The top 12 publicly traded network marketing
companies provide the most reliable information, and
they make up the majority of the largest, most
well-established companies; so I’ll again direct my
analysis towards them. (An informal survey of un-audited
data provided by private network marketing companies
also reinforced the following results.)
From 1990 to 1995, annual industry
sales growth averaged about 16 percent, and some years
was as high as 30 percent. From 1996 to 2000, average
annual sales growth of these public companies—based on
US revenue only—was only 8.7 percent, with a low of just
over 6 percent from 1999 to 2000. The entire direct
selling industry’s growth rate dropped to a 10-year low
of 4.5. It seemed industry growth was about to come to a
grinding halt.
Instead, the growth rate of these
companies from 2000 to 2001 was 14.6 percent—more than
double the previous year’s rate! The slowing trend of
the latter 90’s has unquestionably reversed. This is by
far the strongest signal of coming momentum: not just an
increase in growth, but an increase in the rate of
increase. One year of doubling growth rates
certainly does not guarantee a boom. However, one thing
is certain: every company momentum phase throughout
network marketing history began with that first exciting
period of doubling growth rates. What are the chances
that the same phenomenon holds true for the entire
industry?
There you have it, folks: not one, not
two, but eight solid, powerful indicators of a
forthcoming network marketing explosion.
No one knows exactly when; it could be
next month, it could be next year. It could be any time
in the first half of this decade. All I know for sure is
this: if you get involved now and stay involved, you
will be there when it happens. So hop on, strap yourself
in, and get ready for the ride of your life. It’s gonna
be a blast!
|